Idealism vs. Reality
When Mum and Dad get done their work today, we're driving down to Virginia to spend Christmas with my grandmother. As with nearly everything in my life, I am of two minds about this.
On the one hand, I know that North America treats its elderly in an abominable fashion. We ignore them, patronize them, stick them in homes where we forget about them for most of the year. The general thought (unvoiced, of course) is that old people are a burden, are just holding us youthful people back from doing what we really want to do. My own grandmother has felt the brunt of this neglect -- she is bipolar, and despite the good intentions of my uncle (who lives a three-hour drive away) my mother has twice visited only to find her in a terrible state because she'd stopped taking her lithium, eating, or even getting out of the bed to go to the bathroom. My grandma needed the concerted effort of all her children to convince her to move into an 'assisted living facility' where she can get care if she needs it. Having grandma move in to live with one of us was never considered. Part of me feels like this visit to Williamsburg is only a token effort to assuage guilt, a "Hi Grandma, we love you, really!" flying visit that doesn't actually deal with the day-to-day problems of being an 80-year-old divorcee with bipolar disorder.
On the other hand, my grandma is exasperating. She doesn't hear very well, she gets what Mum calls 'wooly' sometimes, and she doesn't have the wicked sense of humour that many grandparents have. Simply put, she's boring, and that prospect makes me think the next week of visiting won't be very much fun. It will be filled with many slow conversations carried on at a high decibel level, inane comments about how old I am, and discussions of the weather and home decor.
It's hard, because I have all these ideals about how senior citizens should be treated, and yet I don't have much time for my own grandmother. Similarly, as much as I would like to stop the cycle of neglect by having my own parents live with me in their old age, part of me thinks they'd never agree to such a thing, and the other part of me doesn't want them to.
So I don't know. I'll see how this week goes, and then proceed from there as best I can. I have a feeling that as my parent's generation ages (oh, those loudly complaining boomers!) the issue of senior citizens rights will become much more important, and much better researched. So hopefully I'll find a way to treat old people with respect and prolonged attention without becoming miserable while doing it.
5 Comments:
That sounds like a crummy situation, bento. DON'T GO FEELING GUILTY, NOW, OR I WILL SEIZE YOU IN A PAINFUL GRIP NEXT TIME I SEE YOU.
8:54 AM
Agh! So if I feel guilty, you will compound my mental anguish with physical pain? How frightening.
10:23 AM
Having only met your grandma once, feel free to ignore as you see fit.
I think that having your grandmother stay in Virginia is probably what's best for her right now, simply because she's near all her friends who are experiencing the same things as she is. If she moved in with your parents, or any of your aunts or uncles, she'd be leaving behind her life, which she would resent. To just up her and move her across states or countries wouldn't be acknowledging that she is a person with an already established life.
Also, she would probably be given far less independence living with a relative. I mean, what do we know about caring for the elderly. There are whole university degrees and medical specialisations just for that. Living with a relative, she might end up being smothered by good intentions ("Put a sweater on." "That's too far to walk." "Did you take your pills today?" etc.).
I don't know. I'm just trying to put a positive spin on it. I know what you mean. I have all these theories about respecting the elderly, yet I don't think I could handle it if I had to look after either of my parents when they get old.
I hope Virginia is nice. Until yesterday, I thought you were going to Ohio to visit the other American grandparents. Oops :)
1:23 PM
The problem isn't just North America; it's where ever you have the Anglo-Saxon mindset and the nuclear family. We spend our childhood being encouraged to be "independent", we spend our adulthood being in a territorial couple, raising our own children to be independent and then when we get old, we're supposed to quietly relinquish what society has told us to treasure the most--our ability to take care of ourselves. In societies where there is more emphasis on actual families instead of the couple, it's much simpler: parents take care of children until they are too old, and then the children take care of them.
I'm watching this play out with my own parents and grandparents. My dad was talking to me about it, how he and Mum--I guessing it's really only him, though--are realising that if they don't want to end up shoved in a home, they have to learn to behave better towards their adult children, so that when they get old, we're not so opposed to having them live in.
I have to admit I myself prove my own argument; the idea of my mother moving in with me when she's old and crotchety provokes this reaction--"Jesus H. Christ! I spent twenty-two years of my life attempting to move away from her!"
My point in all this ramble? Don't feel guilty. You're having to overcome society's training even to make the drive to see your grandma. Who is as slow as the ICE AGE. (sorry, couldn't help throwing that in.)
4:13 PM
I knew you would ;)
6:04 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home